Posted on 05 April 2011.
By Sam James
India is a vast country – a subcontinent with a medley of colorful people, languages, cultures, traditions and customs. Before the advent of western Government, it was not even known as a single nation and the popular saying was the 56 kingdoms ruled by 56 dynasties. Despite the seeming kaleidoscopic differences there was a spiritual and religious thread that made the string called India. As a nation, we have diversified interests and “Unity in Diversity” has been acclaimed as the greatness of India. Before independence there was only single cause-the liberation of the mother land from foreign yoke. And this expediency necessitated the growth of a Single National Party with a single goal.
Mahatma Gandhi said that after Independence the party should be disbanded and fresh parties should be formed for ruling the country. But the advice of the Father of the Nation was not needed to and freedom fighters who enjoyed the trust of the masses became rulers of the country. The opportunity for a Multi National Party Democracy was thus thwarted and during the Nehru era, the congress was the unquestioned single ruling party. A few national leaders who participated in the Freedom struggle, could not establish an equally popular party like the Congress. Since there was no national cause but for the brief Chinese invasion, rural interests and local type of narrow nationalism thrived and rural and local parties came to power in a few states. The advent of India Gandhi’s rule caused concern among senior leaders and the split of Congress gave place to a semi-national party which alone could not sweep the polls and needed a tactful seat adjustments in the election.
Since people tasted the bitterness of emergency, losing their fundamental rights, the Congress could not get majority and the first coalition government of Morarji Desai was put on the saddle which could not survive the stipulated period could not give a stable government. Congress was voted to power once again and till Rajiv was Prime Minister, the Congress rule existed by poll adjustments in the States dividing the constituencies with local parties. Afterwards India has seen only hung parliaments with no single party majority and coalition government became the order of the day. The credit of successfully running a hung parliament to its full period goes to Mr. Narashima Rao, who despite sarcastic and vitriolic criticism patiently bore the brunt.
The coalitions of Mr.V.P.Singh, Mr. Chandrasekhar, Mr.Gowda, Mr.I.K.Gujral and Mr. Vajpayee could not survive the full period, because of the partners pulling in different directions. Every partner of the coalition has some axe to grind and if it proves futile, the support is withdrawn with the result, the government precariously aborts. Though a common minimum policy, a national agenda, a common program is charted, the implementation brings certain differences of opinion and endangers the government.
In certain cases the partner or the outside supporter brings certain constraints to the government to dismiss the rival party rule in the States. The DMK and the AIADMK governments used to be toppled successively in the past like this. If the coalition government demurs, it is axed and the government falls. Sometimes there may be ulterior motives in the disguise of petty causes to topple the government. The partners in coalition have different narrow political interests, they are egoistic and want to escape from the clutches of the law of the land. The original demand is always clandestine and the toppling is done under masked flimsy reasons. The irony in the fall of the last government was due to a single vote majority. The party which toppled the government do not form a fresh government as it too did not posses unequivocal support of others.
What would be the future of India? No party other than the congress is national party having grass roots in all the States. The States are governed by local parties. Therefore coalition has become an inevitable feature of Indian politics somehow or other, India is learning by trial and error to survive a coalition government to its full term. Already debate has smartest on the formation of national government of a Presidential Form of Democracy. Political parties have started rethinking on their behavior patterns and there is a broad-based give and take policy. Even parties having different ideals and ambitions bury their differences and join hands for a common cause in establishing a stable government at the Centre. Some parties even urge to have twin policy one suitable to the State and another suitable to the nation as a whole. Coalition, though at present looks odd is emerging as the successful type of government suited to the Kaleidoscopic nature of our country, surely it will be successful in future and this will also be a needed model for other developing countries to follow suit. Continue Reading